Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Despite Relocation Drama, Coyotes Overcome Adversity

Gordon Monson of the Salt Lake Tribune asks if some changes to the rules of soccer would make it more appealing to American sports fans.

about 1 year ago Vada-beard_tiny wheatie_87 10 comments 0 recs  | 

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

I think this is a good article by Gordon Monson

I don’t however want to see any changes made to soccer except for maybe goal line cameras/replays to make sure goals count if they cross the line. Also, I would like something to be done about all the flopping and faking of injuries. I agree with Garth Lagerway:

The game shouldn’t tolerate the flopping and faking of injuries. If fans wanted to see bad acting, they’d watch "Jersey Shore." In fact, this part of soccer is the least tolerable by those in the hardcore American sports tradition. Fans here can’t stand that B.S. — in part, because they are brought up playing sports in which toughness is highly valued. Rolling around on the ground, writhing in fake pain, wasting time is pathetic to Americans.

Personally, I don’t care if the average American sports fan enjoys soccer. Changing the rules to satisfy them would ruin the beautiful game that it is. I like being part of something that hasn’t been cheapened by trying to satisfy the majority. I guess you can call me a ‘hipster’.

Long live Ninja!
Rise and shout the Cougars are out!!
Author on VanquishTheFoe.com
Follow me on Twitter: @wheatie_87

by wheatie_87 on May 4, 2011 2:26 AM MDT reply actions  

I think Monson should stick to something he knows

That clearly isn’t soccer, now yes there are some things that should be updated to take advantage of the technology that is available but any changes to the core rules wouldn’t help the US audience get it, or indoor soccer would be huge.

It is really clear that Gordon is looking for relevance in a field that he has no credibility and each time he puts pen to paper he becomes less relevant.

by denz on May 4, 2011 1:23 PM MDT reply actions  

Horrible ideas… it’s not basketball.

by Scott Devey on May 4, 2011 1:49 PM MDT reply actions  

I hate, Hate, HATE the flopping this is so prevalent in the "bigger" leagues

Cristiano Ronaldo is the worst (best, depending on how you mean) at it. And the most recent Barcelona-Real Madrid matches have been tough to watch with all the flopping going on. Yesterday’s Champions League match between them wasn’t as bad as some of the others have been which I’m happy about.

I know it can be a tactic to secure a win, as we saw Monterrey do last week, but I still hate it.

Long live Ninja!
Rise and shout the Cougars are out!!
Author on VanquishTheFoe.com
Follow me on Twitter: @wheatie_87

by wheatie_87 on May 4, 2011 2:06 PM MDT reply actions  

officials can

already card players for diving and while they don’t do it often it is a hard call to make in the run of play.

by denz on May 4, 2011 2:22 PM MDT up reply actions  

I know they can but they don't often

And I said I hate it, but thats just my opinion and I know there’s not much that can be done about it.

Long live Ninja!
Rise and shout the Cougars are out!!
Author on VanquishTheFoe.com
Follow me on Twitter: @wheatie_87

by wheatie_87 on May 4, 2011 2:25 PM MDT up reply actions  

What people forget -

I think – is that soccer is a 90 minute sport. Basketball is only 48, American football is only 60. So there are 30+ minutes extra in a soccer game – which could be considered “overtime” in a basketball game or football game. (Not sure how long hockey games go for). So to me, there is plenty of time for teams to get a win, and in some cases, a draw. And if it ends in a tie, then that’s okay. 90 minutes is enough for the regular season. It’s a free flowing sport with little choppy parts (in most cases). Changing the game too much will only make it choppier – like football and basketball. 90 minutes of constant running should be enough.

by Javi Hernandez on May 4, 2011 6:24 PM MDT reply actions  

I recommend...

…not reading the comments in that article if you’d like to keep your sanity.

by Winston D Flores on May 4, 2011 6:36 PM MDT reply actions  

Maybe Monson should spend more time learning about the game...

then trying to change it.
1) Example 1: The tie. If Monson understood soccer and it’s point system (3 points for a win, 1 for a tie, 0 for a loss) he would start to realize that a tie is not a tie, in that the home team is expected most of the time to get a win (and 3 points) and thus a tie for a hometeam actually means losing 2 important points. Conversely a tie on the road is worth much more than a tie at home.
2) Example 2: Low scoring. Low scoring is what makes soccer interesting. One goal either way can totally changes the complexion of a game. Who gives a crap in basketball until the last 2 minutes if a team scores a (field) goal or not.
3) I can’t stand to watch basketball anymore. I love the game, but the modern game has been ruined by too many stoppages (every 2 minutes at least), too much control from the sidelines and too little autonomy from the players. Basketball would be much more interesting if they changed the rules to be more like soccer. Imagine basketball if you had only 3 subtitutes and no sub reentry during the game. Imagine basketball with no timeouts. Imagine basketball where the players had to improvise and adapt on the fly, and the coach only had halftime to make adjustments. I think it would be a lot more interesting (and I could actually watch an entire game in an hour instead of 3).
Basketball, Football and Baseball have all mutated from how they were played 30-40 years ago. Players just try to execute a pre-determined plan (like robots) that a coach directs. Quarterbacks don’t call their own plays, baseball has very little improvisation allowed.
4) Flopping and time wasting is not soccer, anymore than hockey has to be fighting. It’s there because of how rules are currently interpreted. You could get rid of feigned injuries very quickly. If play is stopped for an injured player, the ref could not allow the “injured” player to re-enter the field for at least 5 minutes (you could sub for him immediately).
5) Call the advantage rule more like hockey. Now a ref has to decide whether to call a foul or play advantage pretty quickly (at least they let it go longer than they did before). When there is a foul, the team fouled should get to continue to play until it loses possession at which time (if a goal is not scored) the free kick goes back to the point of the foul. Like hockey, the fouled team could throw everyone forward with no fear of being scored on. If the team that fouled, fouls again during the time of advantage it would be an automatic yellow (or red) card. If it were to player’s advantage to stay on his feet diving would be eliminated. Refs would call more fouls without having players have to go down to convince the ref to call it (look how many fouls are not called on Messi because he doesn’t go down).
6) Start calling and cracking down on grabbing, especially during free and corner kicks. Players must keep their arms at their sides, not wrapped around the attacker. This would open up the penalty area and more goals would be scored.

by Timoteo on May 4, 2011 8:03 PM MDT reply actions  

More points for more goals.

The one change that would help the game would be to change the points so that if a team gets 4 or more goals and win they get 4 points instead of 3. This would encourage teams to attack and not just defend a lead. Then you would see better games.

by iriepup on May 4, 2011 8:44 PM MDT via mobile reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Real Salt Lake .

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

1eafd23c9c9911e18cf91231380fd29b_7_small
Check it out
Olave_small
Pot meet kettle
Olave_small
Why TFC Deserves our respect
Small
RSL Reserves lose again, but what to do?
Effing_steve_ott_game_small
St. Louis Soccer Fan Desperately Seeking MLS Team

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Bloglogo2_inch_small denz